Why I’m Sitting Out Melodi Grand Prompt

Melodi Grand Prompt is a music competition dedicated to songs created using artificial intelligence—a playful, modern twist on the classic Eurovision Song Contest format, where participants compete to create the best AI-generated track.

When the idea of a competition like this comes up, it’s easy to understand the enthusiasm. It’s playful, it brings together people exploring new tools, and it generates buzz around a technological turning point. For many, it’s both fun and inspiring.

Still, I’m choosing to watch from the sidelines. Not because I’m against AI music or those who think the concept is great, but because the entire premise clashes with how I relate to music in the first place.

Music Isn’t a Sport

The most fundamental reason is simple: I have never been fond of music as a competitive format.

In sports, there is a finish line, a stopwatch, or a scoring system that determines who was fastest, highest, or strongest. Music doesn’t work like that. Music is a deeply subjective experience. A song that hits one listener right in the chest on a rainy Tuesday evening might feel completely indifferent—or downright irritating—to the next person.

Grading art and crowning a “winner” feels to me like comparing apples to melancholy. When music is packaged into a competitive format, the focus subtly shifts from experience and individuality to whatever catches on the widest, fastest, and most immediately. That is an exercise I simply have no need to be part of.

I Make Music 100 Percent for Myself

For me, creating music is about one thing alone: an inner need to express something, explore a mood, or capture an idea that won’t let go. Every single song I work on is created exclusively for my own sake.

When a track is finally released into the world and made available to others, it’s because I feel it is finished and stands firmly on its own two feet. If someone else happens to like it, find comfort in it, or recognize themselves in the atmosphere, that’s certainly nice—but it is entirely secondary.

The moment I started creating or submitting music with an eye toward what a jury or a voting audience might prefer, I would lose the very core of why I do this.

The Human Craft Behind the Scenes

Another reason the competitive format around “prompting” feels slightly off to me is how it can give the impression that AI music is just about typing in a few clever keywords and pressing a button—as if it were some kind of text-based target practice.

That is not what my process looks like at all.

Behind every single song I choose to share with the outside world lies extensive, time-consuming, and deeply human work. I work out the lyrics, often drawing from my own thoughts, experiences, and reflections. What follows is a long process of trial, error, listening, and discarding.

Out of a hundred drafts, maybe one or two will have the nerve, phrasing, or emotional weight I’m looking for. The rest end up in the trash. It’s about curating, editing, fine-tuning, and ruthless quality control where the human ear and gut feeling guide every single choice. The technology is merely an instrument—a tool on par with a synthesizer or a recording studio—while the direction, intention, and selection are one hundred percent human.

Here’s to Diversity—Without a Bib Number

I cheer for everyone who finds joy in exploring what artificial intelligence can do for musical creativity, and I wish those participating in Melodi Grand Prompt all the fun and community the competition brings. We need arenas that challenge old notions and spark debate about what music can be in our time.

Personally, though, I’m most comfortable without a bib number pinned to my chest. I will continue to write, listen, discard, and finish songs at my own pace—completely without a scoreboard, and solely because the music means something to me.