AERIALIS K.

.my blog about music and AI
more on artificial intelligence

Is AI-Generated Work Truly Art?

The rise of artificial intelligence in creative fields has sparked a debate: Can AI-generated images, videos, and music be considered true art? To answer this, we must first define what art actually is.

What Is Art?

Art has been described in countless ways, but a broad and meaningful definition might be:

“Art is the intentional creation of something that evokes emotions, conveys ideas, or expresses creativity, often through visual, auditory, or performative means.”

This definition emphasizes three key elements:

  1. Intentionality – A creator with a vision or purpose.

  2. Expression & Meaning – Something is communicated beyond just its form.

  3. Emotional & Aesthetic Impact – It resonates with an audience.

Where Does AI Fit In?

If we apply this definition to AI-generated content, the answer depends on how AI is used:

  • AI as an Autonomous Creator
    If an AI is left to generate images or music randomly, without human guidance, does it have intentionality? Most would argue no. Without human direction, AI lacks purpose beyond processing data and following patterns.

  • AI as a Creative Tool
    If an artist uses AI as a tool—guiding it, refining its outputs, and injecting their own creative vision—then the work meets the definition of art. The human remains the driving force behind the piece, much like a painter using brushes or a composer using digital instruments.

A New Era of Creativity

For artists who embrace AI, the technology is not a replacement but an enhancement. It allows creators to visualize moods, experiment with soundscapes, and bring ideas to life in ways that were previously impossible. AI expands artistic possibilities rather than diminishing them.

Ultimately, art is not defined by how it is created, but by the intention and emotion behind it. If a piece moves people, makes them think, or expresses something meaningful, then it is art—whether painted by hand, composed with traditional instruments, or shaped with the assistance of artificial intelligence.

Topping the Charts!

AI-generated music is making waves, and ‘Rooftop’, one of my latest tracks, has climbed to the top of the charts in the Facebook group Nordic AI Music Creators, a growing community of digital artists pushing the boundaries of sound and technology.

Blending cutting-edge AI composition with human creativity, Rooftop has resonated with listeners, proving that artificial intelligence is more than just a tool—it’s a collaborator. The track’s rise highlights the evolving landscape of music production, where traditional boundaries are being redefined.

This is exactly why I embrace AI in music. It helps bring my creative vision to life in ways that weren’t possible before.

With AI-generated music gaining recognition, Rooftop‘s success signals a future where human-AI collaboration isn’t just accepted—it’s celebrated.

So what’s next? Only time will tell, but one thing’s for sure: the view from the top is just the beginning!

Sven Arnesen
March 26, 2025